If your California FAIR Plan policy renewed on or after October 15, 2026, the premium on it is the first you have seen under the Plan’s new rates. The number in the news is 29.1 percent. The number on your renewal is probably not 29.1 percent, and the difference is the whole point of this article.
Most of the coverage so far has reported the headline figure and stopped. What a policyholder actually needs to know is what kind of number 29.1 percent is. Why does one property in the hills see a much larger change than a similar house on a flat street two miles away? And what is worth checking before the renewal is paid?
What did the Department of Insurance approve?
The California Department of Insurance approved an overall rate increase of 29.1 percent on the FAIR Plan’s dwelling program. The Plan had filed for 35.8 percent in September 2025. The approval was announced in May 2026, and the new rates apply to every new and renewal dwelling policy with an effective date on or after October 15, 2026.
The dwelling program is the FAIR Plan’s residential book: owner-occupied homes of one to four units, rental dwellings, seasonal rentals, condominium unit owners, and personal property coverage for renters. It does not include the Plan’s commercial program, which has its own rate filings. It also does not include the difference in conditions policy many FAIR Plan households carry alongside the Plan, which comes from a separate insurer with its own approved rates.
Rates, effective dates and filing figures in this section are as approved in 2026. The FAIR Plan is required to file dwelling rates at least every two years, so these figures will change.
Is 29.1 percent a base rate increase or an average?
It is an overall figure, not a uniform one, and the FAIR Plan has been plain about that. In its statement on the approval, the Plan said that not every customer will see their premium rise by this amount. The largest component of the increase relates to the wildfire portion of the premium. Properties at significant wildfire risk will see a higher increase than those at lower risk, and some policyholders will see a premium decrease.
That is how a California rate filing works. The percentage that is approved describes the change in total premium across the whole book of business, weighted by how much premium each policy carries. Underneath that single figure, the individual pieces of the rating plan move by different amounts, and the wildfire charge moved the most. Every policy is then re-rated against the new plan, and the result for any one property depends on which factors apply to it.
In practice, a home with a high wildfire risk score in the Santa Monica Mountains, the San Gabriel foothills or the Santa Clarita canyons is likely to see a change well above 29.1 percent. A rental duplex on a flat lot in an urban neighborhood may see a much smaller change, or a reduction. Two neighbors with the same coverage can open two very different renewal notices, and both are correct.
Why is the wildfire portion doing most of the work?
Because this was the first FAIR Plan rate filing under the Department of Insurance’s Sustainable Insurance Strategy, which prices wildfire risk more directly. That framework lets an insurer’s rates reflect two things California rate regulation had not previously allowed. One is the output of a catastrophe model the Department has reviewed. The other is the net cost of the reinsurance the insurer buys. Both of those are wildfire-driven for a book like the FAIR Plan’s, so both land on the wildfire portion of the premium.
The scale of that book explains the rest. As of September 2026, the end of its fiscal year, the FAIR Plan carried 698,307 dwelling and commercial policies and $773 billion of total exposure, up 252 percent since September 2022. After the Eaton and Palisades fires in January 2025, the Plan handled roughly 5,400 claims and had paid about $3.5 billion by the one-year mark. It needed a $1 billion assessment on its member insurers in February 2025 to keep paying claims. As of January 2026 its reinsurance program starts paying only after the Plan has absorbed the first $1.25 billion of a loss.
The Plan is required by statute to charge rates sufficient to pay its anticipated claims and expenses. It told the Assembly Insurance Committee in January 2026 that its actuarial rate need was roughly 80 percent. It filed for 35.8 percent and was granted 29.1 percent. The two previous dwelling increases were 15.6 percent in 2021 and 15.7 percent in September 2023. This is the largest approved increase in the Plan’s recent history, and the pressure behind it has not gone away.
The exposure, policy count and claims figures above are the FAIR Plan’s own published statistics through September 2026 and its January 2026 legislative testimony. The Plan updates them quarterly.
What happens to the difference in conditions policy?
The rate increase does not change the DIC premium directly. A FAIR Plan dwelling policy is a named peril policy: it responds to fire, lightning, internal explosion and smoke, with windstorm and vandalism available as extended coverage at additional cost. It does not cover water damage, theft or liability. The difference in conditions policy, usually called a DIC, is what fills those gaps, and it is written by a separate carrier under that carrier’s own rates.
What it does change is the total. A household on the FAIR Plan pays two premiums for one house, and the October 15 change moves one of them. When the renewals arrive, it is worth looking at both numbers together rather than reacting to one. The question that matters is what the whole arrangement now costs against what the voluntary market would charge for a single homeowners policy, if one is available. The two policies are companions, not layers, and each responds only to the causes of loss it names. Our page on the FAIR Plan and DIC together walks through how they fit.
Is this the same as the wildfire assessment?
No. The 2025 assessment was charged to the Plan’s member insurers, while the October 15 change is the Plan’s own premium. The $1 billion assessment in February 2025 was levied on the FAIR Plan’s member insurers, not on FAIR Plan policyholders. The Plan does not assess its own customers. Whether and how those insurers recover part of that assessment from their own policyholders is a separate question governed by the Department of Insurance. Where it appears at all, it appears on policies those insurers issue, not on the FAIR Plan policy itself. The October 15 rate change is the FAIR Plan’s own premium, approved through the ordinary rate filing process. The assessment and the rules for recovering it are covered in our history of the FAIR Plan.
Can you lower the wildfire portion?
Yes, within limits, and this is the one part of the premium a policyholder can act on. The FAIR Plan offers twelve wildfire hardening discounts, and they apply to the wildfire portion of the premium, which is the portion that just rose the most. A Dwelling Fire policyholder who qualifies for all twelve may see up to 16.4 percent off that portion. The discounts are applied through your broker and the Plan can change them, so the figures here are as published in November 2025.
The twelve fall into four groups. The first is a single community discount, earned if the home sits in a Fire Risk Reduction Community listed by the Board of Forestry or in a Firewise USA site in good standing.
Five immediate surroundings discounts cover the ground around the house:
- Vegetation and debris cleared from under decks
- Combustible material cleared within five feet of the dwelling
- Only noncombustible fences and gates within that five feet
- Combustible sheds and outbuildings more than 30 feet from the house, or as far away as the lot allows
- Trees trimmed and brush cleared to the defensible space standard in Public Resources Code section 4291
Five structure discounts cover the building itself:
- A Class A fire rated roof
- Enclosed eaves
- Ember resistant vents
- Multi-paned windows or functional shutters
- Six inches of noncombustible material at the base of each exterior wall
The twelfth is a completion discount, earned when all ten of the surroundings and structure items are met.
Several of these are weekend jobs. Clearing the five foot zone, replacing wood fencing where it meets the house and installing ember resistant vents are inexpensive relative to the premium they touch. A Class A roof or new windows are capital projects. Whether they pay back depends on the size of the wildfire portion on your specific renewal, which is why it is worth reading that line before deciding.
Is the voluntary market an option again?
For some properties, yes, and the timing is not an accident. The same Sustainable Insurance Strategy that allowed this rate increase was designed to bring admitted insurers back into wildfire-exposed areas in exchange for rate rules they could work with. The FAIR Plan’s own statistics show the effect. New business in its 2026 fiscal year, which ended in September, averaged 27 percent below the prior year’s monthly pace, even as the total policy count kept growing.
That does not mean every FAIR Plan household can leave. Placement depends on the property, its wildfire score, its claims history, its condition and what each carrier is willing to write in that ZIP code at that moment. What it does mean is that a renewal at a materially higher premium is a reasonable moment to have the property remarketed. Some placements are quick. Others need underwriting review or a surplus lines placement through a licensed surplus line broker, and those take longer. We tell you which applies before you decide anything, and a FAIR Plan renewal can be kept in force while that happens.
What should you check on the renewal before paying it?
Four lines on the declarations page decide most of what happens after a fire, and a rate change is a good reason to read them.
The dwelling limit. The FAIR Plan does not verify that the limit on the policy would rebuild the house, and its own form says the inflation guard is not an opinion that it would. Rebuilding costs move, and most limits were set some time ago. We go through a replacement cost estimator with you and you decide where the limit sits.
The replacement cost endorsement. On a dwelling 25 years old or newer it is included unless it was declined. On an older dwelling it has to be requested, and the roof has to have been replaced within the last 25 years. Without it a total loss settles at actual cash value measured by fair market value, and in a burned neighborhood market value and rebuilding cost can diverge sharply. Our guide to the FAIR Plan covers the endorsement in detail.
Fair Rental Value, if the property is rented. Electing it as a percentage of the dwelling limit reduces the dwelling limit by what is paid. Scheduling it with its own limit does not.
The DIC declarations alongside it. If the dwelling limit changes on the FAIR Plan side, the DIC limit should match, or the two policies stop describing the same house.
What did Sacramento change for FAIR Plan policyholders?
Two FAIR Plan bills became law on September 27, 2026, and neither changes the October 15 premium.
AB 1680, which the Insurance Commissioner calls the Make It FAIR Act, is an oversight bill. It requires the Plan to carry out corrective actions the Department identifies in its examinations, with civil penalties for failures. It also lets the Commissioner require changes to the Plan’s policy limits and add fair rental value coverage to its renters program.
AB 69 changes what the Plan tells you. You will get a notice about moving to the voluntary market when a policy is issued and at each renewal. Starting January 1, 2028, the Plan will share policyholder information, including the broker of record, with insurers in its clearinghouse programs, and you can opt out.
The same law asks brokers to give clients information about those clearinghouse programs and to complete approved training. When a clearinghouse insurer makes an offer, it goes to both the policyholder and the broker of record.
The filing cycle has not changed. The Plan must file dwelling rates at least every two years, and the gap between its stated rate need and what was approved is large. Policyholders should expect another filing, and the wildfire portion of the premium will remain the part that moves.
Legislative status in this section is as of November 2026, after both bills were signed. Implementation dates can shift, so confirm them with the Department of Insurance before relying on them.
Where does this leave you?
The 29.1 percent is real, but it is the average of a spread, and your renewal sits somewhere on that spread according to where the house stands and how it is built. The wildfire portion is doing most of the work, which is also the portion the hardening discounts touch and the portion a voluntary market carrier will look at first. The DIC is unchanged, so the total is what to compare.
If you hold a FAIR Plan policy and the renewal is in front of you, we can read it with you. We can tell you what the wildfire portion is doing on your specific property and check whether the discounts you already qualify for are on it. And we can have the property requoted in the voluntary market so you know what the alternative actually costs. Call the Granada Hills office at 818-322-4744 or request a review. Be insurance wise.
Sources
- California FAIR Plan Association, Key Statistics and Data, figures through September 2026
- California FAIR Plan Association, Dwelling policies and Wildfire Hardening Discounts, applicable as of November 15, 2025
- California FAIR Plan Association, presentation to the Assembly Insurance Committee, January 28, 2026 (rate filing history, exposure, reinsurance retention, assessments, claims paid)
- California FAIR Plan Association statement on the dwelling rate approval, as published by KRCR, May 22, 2026
- California Department of Insurance, Sustainable Insurance Strategy
- California Department of Insurance, press release of September 30, 2026 on the consumer protection bills signed by the Governor, including AB 1680
- California Legislature, AB 1680, California FAIR Plan Association (Chapter 540, Statutes of 2026)
- California Legislature, AB 69, FAIR Plan policy notices and renewals (Chapter 496, Statutes of 2026)
- California Public Resources Code section 4291
Disclaimer
This article is provided by Schneiderman Insurance Agency for general informational purposes only. It is not legal, tax, financial, claims, or coverage advice. We are licensed insurance professionals, not attorneys, accountants, or financial advisors, and nothing here should be relied on as a substitute for advice from a qualified professional in those fields. This content is general in nature and is not a review of, or a recommendation for, any individual reader’s specific insurance needs, policies, or circumstances. Insurance coverage depends entirely on the specific terms, conditions, endorsements, exclusions, limits, underwriting eligibility, carrier, and facts of each situation, and the actual policy language always controls. We do not guarantee any coverage, pricing, eligibility, underwriting approval, or claim outcome. Reading this article does not create an agent-client relationship. To understand how these issues apply to your situation, please review your own policy and speak with a licensed insurance professional, and consult legal, tax, or financial advisors where appropriate.
The 1933 Long Beach Earthquake, The Field Act, And The Gap It Left BehindDon’t forget to share this article
The next step is easy, call us at 818-322-4744, or click below to start your insurance quote
Related Articles
California passed two earthquake laws in the spring of 1933, six weeks apart. One of them produced a ...
8.7 min read/A 100-unit California apartment building looks different to its investor, its lender, the city, its insurer and its residents. How rising insurance costs move value, loan covenants and claim outcomes, and why coverage responds to actual use, not intended use.
25.8 min read/Your contractor's insurance protects your contractor. What a California homeowner should require before demolition, remodel or construction begins, what additional insured status actually gives you, and where Civil Code 2782 leaves a homeowner on their own.
20.9 min read/








