Updated November 19, 2026.
You drop your car at a repair shop on a Thursday. The part is on backorder, so the car spends the weekend on the lot. On Monday the shop calls. Overnight, someone cut the catalytic converter out from under it, and the shop says you need to call your own insurance company.
Most people assume that when a car is damaged at a repair shop, the shop’s insurance pays. Sometimes it does. Often it does not. The reason sits in a single choice on the shop’s policy that almost no customer ever sees, and that many shop owners made years ago without much thought.
The short answer: if the shop was careless, the shop or its insurer generally pays. If the shop was not at fault, as with many thefts, fires and floods, it depends on the shop’s garagekeepers coverage. Under the most common version, the loss generally goes to your own comprehensive coverage, if you carry it.
The choice is called the garagekeepers basis. This article explains what it is and why it decides who pays. It also covers what customers and shop owners can do before a loss, instead of finding out after one.
Is a repair shop responsible when my car is damaged in its care?
A repair shop is responsible for your car while it has it, but only up to a legal standard, not as a guarantor. California treats a shop that holds your car for pay as a depositary for hire. Civil Code section 1852 says a depositary for hire “must use at least ordinary care” to preserve what it holds.
Ordinary care is what a reasonable shop would do in the same situation. Locking the lot, keeping keys secure, parking cars sensibly and supervising test drives are part of it. If the shop falls short and your car is damaged, the shop is generally responsible.
If the shop used reasonable care and something still happened, the answer can change. In an unpublished 2015 California Court of Appeal decision, a customer’s 1957 Chevrolet Bel Air was stolen when thieves burglarized the shop. The court upheld summary judgment for the shop. The shop had kept the car in a locked garage inside a fenced lot with a monitored alarm, and that evidence was undisputed.
A sign at the counter or a line on the repair order does not change the standard. In Gardner v. Downtown Porsche Audi (1986), a California appeals court held that a garage cannot use a waiver to escape liability for its own negligence. Under Civil Code section 1668, the court found such a clause invalid because auto repair affects the public interest. A “not responsible for theft” notice may discourage a claim, but it does not excuse carelessness.
So the law splits losses into two kinds. Some are the shop’s fault, and some are not. Which kind you have decides whether the shop’s insurance has to pay at all.
Isn’t that what the shop’s garage liability insurance is for?
Garage liability is not built for damage to your car while the shop holds it. “Garage liability” is the market name for the general liability and business auto coverage that protects a shop when its operations injure someone or damage other people’s property. A customer slipping in the waiting room or a mechanic’s test drive hitting another car are typical claims.
The general liability part excludes property in the shop’s care, custody or control, and it excludes most claims arising from autos. That leaves your car, sitting in the shop’s care, outside it. The coverage written for that gap is called garagekeepers.
One related rule helps drivers. If a technician crashes your car on a test drive and hurts someone, California generally makes the shop’s auto liability policy pay first. Under Insurance Code section 11580.9(a)(1), when a vehicle is being operated by someone in the business of repairing or servicing vehicles, that business’s policy is primary. That rule covers injuries and damage to others, though, not damage to your own car.
What is garagekeepers coverage?
Garagekeepers coverage pays for loss to customers’ vehicles while a shop is servicing, repairing, parking or storing them. The standard version is an endorsement, ISO form CA 99 37 (PDF), added to the shop’s business auto policy.
The shop chooses several things when it buys it. Each choice affects what a customer can expect later:
- Which causes of loss are covered. Comprehensive covers almost anything except collision or overturn. Specified causes covers only fire, lightning, explosion, theft, and mischief or vandalism. Collision is a separate choice.
- The limit. The limit applies per location, for each loss, no matter how many cars are involved. A lot fire that damages ten cars shares one limit.
- The deductible. It usually applies per customer car, with a maximum for theft or vandalism in any one event.
- Which locations are listed. Coverage applies at the locations scheduled on the policy.
The form’s definition of loss includes resulting loss of use, which matters when you need a rental while a claim is sorted out.
Garagekeepers has its own exclusions. The standard form does not cover faulty work the shop performed or defective parts. It also excludes theft or conversion by the shop’s own employees, which belongs on a separate crime policy. Sound equipment that is not permanently installed and radar detectors are excluded too.
What is the difference between legal liability, direct excess and direct primary?
Legal liability, direct excess and direct primary differ in whether the shop’s garagekeepers pays only when the shop is at fault, or regardless of fault. This is the choice that decides most “who pays” arguments, and it comes in three versions.
Legal liability pays only when the shop is legally responsible for the damage. If a technician backs your car into a post, it pays. If a wildfire, a flood or a determined thief damages your car despite the shop’s reasonable care, it does not pay, because the shop was not at fault. An Insurance Journal analysis describes legal liability as “the most common” option. Specialty insurance distributor Jencap calls it the most common form and the least expensive.
Direct excess keeps the legal liability coverage and adds coverage that applies regardless of fault, but pays after the customer’s own insurance. If the shop is at fault, it responds the way legal liability does. If the shop is not at fault, your comprehensive or collision coverage goes first. The shop’s garagekeepers can then pick up what your policy does not, such as your deductible, depending on the policy terms. If you have no coverage that applies, direct excess can pay the loss. The same Insurance Journal analysis calls it the rarest of the three.
Direct primary pays regardless of fault, and it pays first. Your own insurer does not have to be involved. It is the broadest option and typically the most expensive.
| Basis | Pays when the shop is at fault | Pays when the shop is not at fault | Whose insurance goes first |
|---|---|---|---|
| Legal liability | Yes | No | The customer’s, when the shop is not at fault |
| Direct excess | Yes | Yes | The customer’s, then the shop’s, when the shop is not at fault |
| Direct primary | Yes | Yes | The shop’s |
How do customers find out only after a loss?
Customers usually learn which version a shop carries on the day something goes wrong. The catalytic converter example is a real pattern in California. Nationally, 37% of catalytic converter theft claims tracked in 2021 were in California, according to National Insurance Crime Bureau data reported by KQED. Repair lots full of parked cars are an obvious target.
If the shop carries legal liability and its lot was reasonably secured, its insurer may decline the claim. The customer is then sent to their own policy. That works only if the customer carries comprehensive coverage, and only after the deductible.
Not everyone has that coverage. About 80% of insured drivers buy comprehensive coverage, according to a Triple-I analysis of 2023 NAIC data. That leaves roughly one in five insured drivers with nothing that pays for theft, fire or vandalism to their own car.
Wildfire raises the same question on a larger scale. The January 2025 Eaton and Palisades fires destroyed 9,414 and 6,837 structures (PDF), according to Los Angeles County. A wildfire that reaches a shop is generally not the shop’s fault. Under legal liability garagekeepers, cars destroyed there generally fall back on each owner’s comprehensive coverage.
When the shop is at fault, the picture is different. Its garagekeepers should respond under any of the three versions, as long as the shop bought the cause of loss involved. Collision, for example, is a separate purchase. If you claim on your own policy instead, your insurer may pursue the shop afterward, which can recover your deductible.
How do shop owners find out after a loss?
Shop owners often find out the same way their customers do. The basis was picked when the policy was first bought, frequently on price, and nobody looked at it again. Then a theft ring, a fire or a flood turns a coverage detail into a dozen angry customers at once.
The legal answer and the business answer can differ. A shop with legal liability coverage may owe nothing to a customer whose car was stolen from a well-secured lot. Telling a loyal customer to file on their own insurance, and pay their own deductible, is still a hard conversation. That is the main reason some shops pay more for a direct basis.
Owners also tend to discover limits and exclusions late:
- A limit sized for an average day. A per-location limit has to absorb the most valuable group of cars that could be on the lot at once, not the typical one.
- An unlisted location. An overflow lot, a second building or a mobile service van may not be scheduled.
- Employee theft. Theft by the shop’s own staff is excluded from garagekeepers and needs a crime policy.
- Faulty work. The cost to redo a bad repair is excluded, though resulting damage may be treated differently.
- A business owners policy instead of garagekeepers. Where carriers have adopted it, ISO’s 2025 program allows many auto service shops on a business owners policy, but its standard customer-auto coverage is narrower. Our auto service and repair shop insurance page explains that trade-off.
What should I ask before I leave my car at a shop?
Ask whether the shop’s insurance pays for damage to your car regardless of fault. A shop that carries direct primary or direct excess garagekeepers can usually answer that quickly. A few more questions are worth the minute they take:
- Where will my car be kept overnight, inside or on an open lot?
- Is the lot fenced, lit and monitored?
- Who will drive my car, and for what?
- What happens to personal items I leave inside?
Then check your own policy. Know whether you carry comprehensive and collision coverage, what your deductibles are, and whether you have rental reimbursement and the other perks your auto policy may include. Photograph your car, including the odometer and any existing damage, when you drop it off.
If something goes wrong and you cannot resolve it with the shop, the Bureau of Automotive Repair takes consumer complaints about auto repair shops and can help mediate a dispute. Questions about how your own insurer handles the claim go to the California Department of Insurance.
What should a shop owner review at renewal?
Review the garagekeepers basis first, because it decides how most customer-car claims will end. Then confirm that the rest of the coverage matches how the shop actually operates:
- Basis. Legal liability, direct excess or direct primary, and whether the price difference is worth the customer relationships it protects.
- Causes of loss. Comprehensive, specified causes or collision, and whether each one is actually purchased.
- Limit. Sized to the peak value of customer cars at each location, including high-value vehicles.
- Deductibles. The per-car deductible and the per-event maximum for theft or vandalism.
- Locations. Every lot, building and service van where customer cars are kept or worked on.
- Gaps. A crime policy for employee theft, and how faulty work and electronics are handled.
Our garagekeepers insurance page covers limits and placement in more detail. The garage insurance page explains how garage liability and garagekeepers fit together.
Final thoughts
When a car is damaged at a repair shop, the question is rarely “is there insurance?” It is “which insurance, and does it pay for this kind of loss?” The answer turns on whether the shop was careless and which garagekeepers basis it chose.
Customers can ask before they hand over the keys. Shop owners can choose deliberately instead of by default. Either way, it is far better to know the answer on drop-off day than on the day of the loss.
If you are a driver and want to check your comprehensive coverage, deductibles or rental reimbursement, start with our auto insurance page or request an auto quote.
If you own a shop and would like to review your garagekeepers basis and limits, call Schneiderman Insurance Agency at (818) 322-4744.
Legal and coverage points current as of November 2026 and specific to California. Form references are to standard ISO wording; carrier forms vary, and the policy language controls.
Sources
- California Civil Code section 1852 (depositary for hire, ordinary care)
- California Civil Code section 1668
- Gardner v. Downtown Porsche Audi (Cal. Ct. App. 1986)
- Dzharadzhyan v. Exclusive Motorcars, Inc. (Cal. Ct. App., 2d Dist., Mar. 5, 2015, B252832, unpublished), case summary
- California Insurance Code section 11580.9
- ISO CA 99 37, Garagekeepers Coverage (specimen via Big I) (PDF)
- Insurance Journal, “Garage Liability or Garagekeepers? That Is the Question” (Feb. 10, 2014)
- Jencap, “What Is Garage Liability Insurance?”
- Big I, “ISO Expands Businessowners Classes Covering Garage Operations” (2025)
- KQED, “California Is a Hot Spot for Catalytic Converter Theft”
- Triple-I, Facts and Statistics: Auto Insurance
- Los Angeles County, Eaton and Palisades Fires anniversary fact sheet (PDF)
- California Bureau of Automotive Repair, complaints
Disclaimer
This article is provided by Schneiderman Insurance Agency for general informational purposes only. It is not legal, tax, financial, claims, or coverage advice. We are licensed insurance professionals, not attorneys, accountants, or financial advisors, and nothing here should be relied on as a substitute for advice from a qualified professional in those fields. This content is general in nature and is not a review of, or a recommendation for, any individual reader’s specific insurance needs, policies, or circumstances. Insurance coverage depends entirely on the specific terms, conditions, endorsements, exclusions, limits, underwriting eligibility, carrier, and facts of each situation, and the actual policy language always controls. We do not guarantee any coverage, pricing, eligibility, underwriting approval, or claim outcome. Reading this article does not create an agent-client relationship. To understand how these issues apply to your situation, please review your own policy and speak with a licensed insurance professional, and consult legal, tax, or financial advisors where appropriate.
Your FAIR Plan renewal went up. Here is what the 29.1 percent actually meansDon’t forget to share this article
The next step is easy, call us at 818-322-4744, or click below to start your insurance quote
Related Articles
Renewal notices at the new FAIR Plan rates are arriving now. The 29.1 percent is an average of a wide spread, and the wildfire portion is doing most of the work.
12.6 min read/California passed two earthquake laws in the spring of 1933, six weeks apart. One of them produced a ...
8.7 min read/A 100-unit California apartment building looks different to its investor, its lender, the city, its insurer and its residents. How rising insurance costs move value, loan covenants and claim outcomes, and why coverage responds to actual use, not intended use.
25.8 min read/









